South East Shipping News

Now in six languages at www.southeastshippingnews.com An elegant, detailed and accurate news site for those interested in the maritime business in the Southeastern United States, Caribbean and Central America

  • Home
  • Archives
  • Profile
  • Subscribe

Haiti faces 30-year recovery: U.S. official

Mike Blanchfield, The Canadian Press
Sunday, May 27, 2012 - 20:15
People walk inside the Jean Marie Vincent camp for people displaced by the devastating 2010 earthquake in Port-au-Prince, Haiti, on May 10, 2012. It will take Haiti the better part three decades to become a middle income country on par with its Caribbean island neighbour, the Dominican Republic, says the top U.S. official on the file. THE CANADIAN PRESS/AP - Dieu Nalio Chery

OTTAWA - It will take Haiti the better part of three decades to become a middle income country on par with its Caribbean island neighbour, the Dominican Republic, says the top U.S. official on the file.

But Thomas Adams, the State Department's special co-ordinator for Haiti, told The Canadian Press that "realistic" estimate should not be seen as daunting to countries like Canada that are heavily invested in helping the Western Hemisphere's poorest country, still struggling after its devastating 2010 earthquake.

Nor should it deter investors, who are crucial to Haiti's long-term recovery, Adams added, as long as the country builds credible democratic institutions.

"There is no reason why Haiti can't become a middle income country. But because they're starting so low, it's going be to be 25-30 years even if they have good economic growth," Adams said in an exclusive interview, after two days of meetings in Ottawa with various government officials.

"It's not a quick fix. These problems in Haiti - their educational system, their health system, cholera, the infrastructure - these aren't quick fixes," he added.

"It's good to be realistic. That's not to say we're not making progress each year … But overall, you're not going to see a Haiti the way you'd like it for a while."

Forty years ago, Haiti was slightly ahead of the Dominican Republic economically, said Adams, with 20 large American corporations setting up their Caribbean headquarters there. The two countries share the Caribbean island of Hispaniola.

Adams sees economic growth for Haiti in textiles, agriculture and tourism.

"Haiti needs private investment. All the donor money, as generous as it is - and I think Canada and a lot of countries have been very generous - isn't enough to fix Haiti."

The U.S. and Canada, said Adams, remain in lock-step when it comes to helping Haiti recover from the devastating January 2010 earthquake that left 300,000 dead and displaced 1.5 million. Canada has pledged more than $1 billion to Haiti, making it the second largest aid recipient after Afghanistan.

That co-operation extends to co-ordinated messaging of Haiti's political leaders, to break the political paralysis of the last year - a crisis that has raised serious questions about the country's ability to stave off corruption and govern itself effectively.

That crisis appeared to ease earlier this month when President Michel Martelly swore in a new prime minister, Laurent Lamothe, whose predecessor resigned in February after barely four months on the job.

The turmoil rendered Haiti's government rudderless and left billions of dollars of donor pledges in limbo.

"That's pretty much over," said Adams. "There's a truce between the president and the parliament. It seems they're willing to work together. The president has confidence in the new prime minister."

With Lamothe confirmed, parliamentary amendments will pave the way for elections of senators and local officials, as well as paving the way for reforms of the court system, said Adams.

Throughout it all, the Canadian and U.S. governments have continued to "give co-ordinated messages on some sensitive topics."

The underlying message can be boiled down to this: reign in the corruption and work together politically.

"That's one of our constant messages," Adams explained.

"We don't say, if you're not going to do X, Y, and Z we're going to cut off all of your aid. But we do say, and Canada says, and everybody else says, over time businessmen and donors are going to go elsewhere if you're not seen as making your best efforts to curb corruption to bring in the rule of the law and be democratic.

"I think they're hearing that."

Diane Ablonczy, Canada's junior foreign affairs for the Americas, said Haitians are "crying out for leadership" so Canada is urging its leaders to step up and provide it.

"We are really urging the new government as its formed to emphasize and really roll up its sleeves and emphasize the need to deliver results for strong institutions in Haiti."

Adams also lauded Canada's former governor general, Haitian-born Michaelle Jean, as a key player in that co-ordinated communication effort with Haiti's leadership.

Jean, now the UNESCO Special Envoy for Haiti, travels to Haiti again this week, for meetings will political leaders. She'll also take part in events to highlight programs that help curb malnutrition and poverty.

Earlier this month, Jean laid bare her frustration with the pace of change in her native country during a recent speech in Ottawa to government officials and non-governmental organizations.

"The aid and handout system has become kind of a business model, a scheme used by some to wheel and deal as it generates opportunities for embezzlement and corruption," Jean said the text posted on her website.

"It can't go on like this."

Adams said that's the message the U.S., Canada and other allies continue to deliver to Haiti.

"We're on the same message too. Again, cut the chaos," he said. "That's all we're saying there: come on guys, let's keep our eye on the ball here."

Comments (0) | TrackBack (0)

PORT-AU-PRINCE, Haiti — The Haitian government is drafting legislation for the newly emerging mining industry to help this impoverished Caribbean nation reap benefits, the new prime minister said Tuesday.

Laurent Lamothe, who saw his Cabinet and policy plan approved hours earlier, told The Associated Press during an interview that the legislation will be sent to Parliament soon. It will lay out rules apportioning royalties for the government and setting protections for the people and environment that could be affected by mines.

“The most important thing is to have the correct mining law,” he said. “It ensures that the right portion comes to the state. It ensures that the people living in the region where the mines are, that their rights are protected. It ensures environmental protection.”

The plans to draft the mining legislation come after the AP reported that two mining companies have begun drilling in Haiti’s northeastern mountains. The companies say testing indicates the precious metals such as gold, copper and silver is worth potentially $20 billion.

That would be a boon for Haiti, which is one of the world’s poorest countries. Most of its 10 million people live on less than $2 a day.

Until the story, few Haitians knew about the recent efforts to mine their country. Mining camps are unmarked, and the work is being done in remote villages on the opposite side of the country from the capital, Port-au-Prince.

U.S. and Canadian investors have spent more than $30 million in recent years on exploratory drilling along with camps for workers, new roads, offices and laboratory studies of samples.

Haiti’s mining potential has been known for several decades. In the 1970s, United Nations geologists documented significant pockets of gold and copper ore, but foreigners weren’t willing to take a risk in a country where corruption and political instability have long discouraged foreign investment.

Mining laws in Haiti haven’t been revised since 1976.

Lamothe said the legislation being drafted is meant to benefit Haiti while also making the country attractive to outside investors by allowing companies to profit from mining.

When asked how much he would like Haiti to receive, Lamothe said: “As much as possible without hampering also the revenue of the party, allowing them to do business.”

The interview came after Lamothe introduced the ministers of his Cabinet, which was approved by Parliament on Monday. The government includes two new posts, a minister to deal with poverty and another to support farmers.

In addition to the mining legislation, Lamothe said his government wants to introduce programs that will clean Port-au-Prince’s garbage-strewn streets by using firefighters and other workers, better maintain roads and help mothers living in the capital’s poorer neighborhoods.

Lamothe, a former telecommunications executive, officially became prime minister Monday night following the approval of his Cabinet and government plan. There had been a nearly three-month vacancy after President Michel Martelly’s first prime minister resigned after only four months on the job.

The absence of a prime minister and fully functioning government has hobbled efforts to rebuild after the 2010 earthquake.

Copyright 2012 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Comments (0) | TrackBack (0)

South Florida exports boom, creating jobs

 

 

May 05, 2012|By Doreen Hemlock, SunSentinel

 With the U.S. economy recovering slowly, more South Florida companies are turning to sales overseas, fueling record exports and adding jobs.

 South Florida is the only U.S. area whose ports consistently ship more to foreign ports than they bring in. Port Everglades now ranks as Florida's top seaport for exports, U.S. commerce statistics show.

 Associated Aircraft Manufacturing and Sales Inc. of Fort Lauderdale illustrates the export boom. It makes and sells parts for aircraft, including electronic systems for military planes.

Since 2010, the company has grown from 52 to 85 employees and from roughly $25 million to $40 million in yearly revenue, thanks to sales mainly to the Middle East and Asia, Chief Executive Frank Lannon said.

"To export, you have to make the investment to study foreign markets, learn what buyers want and adapt products to meet those needs", Lannon said. "You can't sit and wait for someone to come to you. You have to go out and sell yourself."

 Custom Biologicals of Deerfield Beach grew from eight to 11 employees last year, thanks to sales mainly in Thailand, Malaysia, Indonesia and Ecuador. One top-seller: bacteria that help plants grow bigger and faster. The product has been used by growers who set world records for giant pumpkins in the last two years, each pumpkin weighing more than 1810 pounds, said the company's executive vice president, Chuck Baugh. 

Exports now account for roughly 70 percent of Custom Biologicals' sales, up from 53 percent in 2010. Revenue set a record last year and is rising this year too, likely requiring more hiring, Baugh said.

 A weaker U.S. dollar has stoked overseas sales, making U.S. goods cheaper in other countries, exporters said.

 More competitive prices help explain why South Florida seaports and airports shipped a record $69.2 billion in goods to foreign ports last year, or $25.7 billion more than they brought in. South Florida exports jumped 18 percent for the year, faster than the 16 percent gains nationwide, according to Coral Gables-based publisher WorldCity.

 Through February, South Florida exports kept climbing: up 11 percent from a year earlier, slightly faster than the U.S. average, WorldCity said. Among top shipments out: high-tech equipment, including cellphones and computers; heavy equipment for construction; medical equipment and pharmaceuticals. Many items are made elsewhere and transit South Florida for sale in Latin America, WorldCity President Ken Roberts said.

 

The Obama administration in 2010 set a goal to double U.S. exports in five years, creating up to 2 million new jobs. Numerous programs are now available to help small- and mid-size companies boost sales overseas.

 

For South Florida businesses looking to increase exports, WorldCity's Roberts and other experts advise:

 

Do your homework. Research specific markets. Study where competitors sell overseas.

 

Talk with people active overseas. Florida's bi-national chambers of commerce, such as the Brazilian-American Chamber, can help.

 

Make a commitment to export. Invest time, money and staff.

 

Set up financing. To get paid, consider requiring payment in advance, or work with lenders to help buyers finance purchases.

 

Comments (0) | TrackBack (0)

The Nassau Guardian.

Comments (0) | TrackBack (0)

  • inShare
  • Email
  • Print
  • Reprints
  • Comments

Send this story to a friend

 

 

Processing...

PortMiami dredge opposition dropped after $1.4M agreement

South Florida Business Journal

Date: Wednesday, April 25, 2012, 6:21pm EDT

Related:

Logistics & Transportation, Miami-Dade County
Enlarge Image
PortMiami

Opposition to the PortMiami dredge project has been dropped, allowing the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to receive an environmental permit and proceed with construction.

The Tropical Audubon Society, Biscayne Bay Waterkeepers and county resident Dan Kipnis agreed to withdraw their opposition to the issuance of a Florida Department of Environmental Protection    Florida Department of Environmental Protection  permit in exchange for a $1.4 million agreement, which still requires Miami-Dade County commission approval.

The permit would allow the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to move forward with the construction phase of the deep dredge project, which will deepen the PortMiami channel to 50 feet to accommodate larger container cargo vessels expected after the Panama Canal expansion in 2014.

The agreement would authorize $1.31 million from the seaport department to the county’s Biscayne Bay Environmental Enhancement Trust Fund, a $50,000 donation to the Tropical Audubon Society and a $50,000 donation to the Biscayne Bay Waterkeepers, according to county documents. The settlement agreement still requires approval from the county commission, which is scheduled to vote on the item on May 1.

“This is a win-win for the entire community,” said Miami-Dade Mayor Carlos Gimenez, in a statement. “The agreement provides additional funding for important environmental projects, while at the same time allowing for the timely completion of the dredge project, which is critical to our efforts to grow our container cargo traffic and create thousands of new, well-paying jobs in our community.”

Comments (0) | TrackBack (0)

The 2012 hurricane season for the Atlantic Ocean, Gulf of Mexico and Caribbean

The 2012 Atlantic hurricane season should be relatively tame with a total of 12 named storms and seven hurricanes

Hurricane Andrew 20th Anniversary web site: Post your photos and stories www.andrew20th.com

Forecasts of hurricane activity are issued before each hurricane season by noted hurricane experts Philip J. Klotzbach, William M. Gray, and their associates at Colorado State University; and separately by NOAA forecasters. CSU’s December 2011 discussion was notable in that the forecasting team announced it would no longer attempt quantitative forecasting nearly six months out, noting …forecasts of the last 20 years have not shown real-time forecast skill. They will, however, release a quantitative forecast for 2012 in April.

Three hurricanes are expected to be « major » with sustained winds of at least 111 miles per hour, with Category 3 or greater status on the Saffir-Simpson intensity scale, Weather Services International (WSI) said in its early pre-season forecast.

The Atlantic hurricane season officially starts on June 1 and ends November 30 and 2011 saw a total of 19 named or tropical storms of which seven became hurricanes, including three major hurricanes.

Irene was the lone hurricane to hit the United States in 2011, but it was first one to do so since Hurricane Ike struck southeast Texas in 2008. Irene was also the most significant tropical cyclone to strike the Northeast since Hurricane Bob in 1991, according to U.S. government forecasters.

In its forecast on Tuesday, WSI chief meteorologist Todd Crawford said the North Atlantic Ocean had cooled to levels unobserved in a decade, fueling hopes for a relatively mild 2012 storm season.

Crawford was also quoted as saying most forecast models suggest an end to the cyclical La Nina weather phenomenon, which fosters hurricane formation.

Crawford stopped short of making any specific predictions about possible hurricane landfalls in 2012, saying there were no strong signals about any threats to the U.S. coastline so far. But he said the energy-rich U.S. Gulf of Mexico and Florida may see some increase in storms. For 2012, our landfall model depicts close-to-normal probabilities of landfall along the U.S. coastline, slightly elevated chances in the Gulf and Florida and slightly reduced chances along the East Coast, he said.

The team predicted:

  • A 45 percent chance of an above-average THC and no El Niño development, raising hurricane activity to about 140 percent of the average season, with 12-15 named storms, seven to nine hurricanes, and three to four major hurricanes.
  • A 30 percent chance of an above-average THC and a “significant” El Niño, reducing hurricane activity to about 75 percent of the average hurricane season — eight to 11, three to five, and one to two.
  • A 15 percent chance of an “unusually strong” THC and no El Niño, bringing activity nearly double the average — 14 to 17, nine to 11, and four to five.
  • A 10 percent chance of a weak THC and a a significant El Niño, bringing activity at 40 percent of the average season, or five to seven named storms, two to three hurricanes, and zero to one major hurricane.

Pre-season forecasts

On December 7, 2011, Tropical Storm Risk (TSR), a public consortium that compromises experts on insurance, risk management and seasonal climate forecasting at University College London, issued an extended-range forecast predicting an above-average hurricane season. In its report, TSR noted that tropical cyclone activity could be about 49% above the 1950-2010 average, with 14.1 (±4.2) tropical storms, 6.7 (±3.0) hurricanes, and 3.3 (±1.6) major hurricanes anticipated, and a cumulative ACE index of 117 (±58). On December 21, 2011, Weather Services International (WSI) issued an extended-range forecast predicting a near average hurricane season. In its forecast, WSI noted that a cooler North Atlantic Oscillation not seen in a decade, combined with weakening La Niña, would result in a near average season with 12 named storms, 7 hurricanes, and 3 major hurricanes. They also predicted a near average probability of a hurricane landfall on the USA coastline, with a slightly elevated chance on the Gulf Coast and a slightly reduced chance along the East Coast.

2012 storm names

The following names will be used for named storms that form in the North Atlantic in 2011 :

Alberto, Beryl, Chris, Debby, Ernesto, Florence, Gordon, Helene, Isaac, Joyce, Kirk, Leslie, Michael, Nadine, Oscar, Patty, Rafael, Sandy, Tony, Valerie, William

Atlantic hurricane season 2011Predictions

Named Storms : 12

Named Hurricanes : 7

Named Storm Days : 85

Hurricane Days : 40

Intense Hurricanes : 3

Net Tropical Cyclone Activity : 165

Landfall Probabilities for 2012

For the 2012 season, Klotzbach and Gray expect an active season overall, but with normal intensity for the Atlantic and a normal impact rating on the U.S. coast. In terms of numbers, they forecast 11 named storms, six hurricanes and two intense hurricanes and a more active recent average of 15 named storms, eight hurricanes and four intense hurricanes.

An average Atlantic hurricane season has 12 named storms, 6 hurricanes, and 2 major hurricanes.

Probabilities of the affected territories

These are finally probabilities that certain territories will be affected by an intense hurricane in 2012:

  • A 58% chance that at least one major hurricane will make landfall on the U.S. coastline in 2012. The long-term average probability is 52%.
  • For the U.S. East Coast, including the Florida Peninsula, the probability of a major hurricane making landfall is 49% (the long-term average is 31%).
  • For the Gulf Coast from the Florida Panhandle west to Brownsville, the probability is 48% (the long-term average is 30%).
  • The team predicts the probability of a major hurricane making landfall in the Caribbean as 62% (average for the last century is 42%).

Comments (0) | TrackBack (0)

New buyer scraps condo plans at Miami River parcel

April 24, 2012 04:30PM

A rendering of the planned Nautica on the River condo

A development site along the Miami River that was slated for a condomionium development could become home to a marina and mixed-use building, after a new buyer picked it up at a steep discount. The South Florida Business Journal reported that Miami-based Pacific National bank sold the 2.7-acre site, at 555 NW South River Drive, for $3.15 million to Zerby Interests. The price represents a 32 percent discount from the $4.6 million mortgage, taken out by Shear Construction and Development, on which it foreclosed. Shear had planned a 192-unit Nautica on the River condominium.

Simply Marinas President Michelle Adiba Ash, who represented the bank, said Zerby is considering the aforementioned marina and mixed-use plan at the site, which is zoned for marine industrial use.

Comments (0) | TrackBack (0)

Pm Unveils Agenda For Grand Bahama

 

#BY DENISE MAYCOCK

#Tribune Freeport Reporter

#dmaycock@tribunemedia.net

#FREEPORT - Prime Minister Hubert Ingraham unveiled the FNM's "Recovery and Growth Agenda for Grand Bahama", which he said will restore and strengthen the island's economy.

photo

#He said a Grand Bahama Development Board will be created to promote the further development of business on the island.

#"We intend to utilise Grand Bahama as a major hub for promoting and incentivising the establishment of both an aircraft registry and a yacht registry," Mr Ingraham told supporters in Grand Bahama on Saturday.

#He stressed that the FNM has big plans for the island.

#Mr Ingraham said his government will use the island's unique location and the Grand Bahama Transshipment Centre and adjacent land to facilitate the development of a "logistic distribution hub" for international cargo in an "effective" free trade zone.

#He believes this will provide a significant boost to Grand Bahama's economy in many areas.

#The prime minister revealed that the FNM will also implement the "Back to the Island Initiative" to attract investment from Bahamians overseas.

#To achieve this, he said, the Bahamas Investment Authority will set up an Economic and Development Council of Bahamians Overseas.

#"The council will advise the government in locating and promoting investment in the Bahamas by the Bahamian diaspora throughout the world.

#"Just like we want Bahamians to go back to the islands, we want people of Bahamian birth or ancestry overseas to invest in the Bahamas.

#"We hope that such a council may also encourage Bahamians overseas to give back in terms of scholarships and other assistance to help develop the talent of young Bahamians," he said.

#Mr Ingraham said the Recovery and Growth Agenda would focus on conducting strategic overseas investment promotions in Latin America and Asia.

#The prime minister said that in the first year of their next term, he will lead an economic and trade mission to Brazil.

#"We also need to be bolder in going after markets in Brazil and Latin America in terms of foreign direct investment, tourism, financial services, maritime services, general trade and cultural exchanges," he said.

#"Just as I have led other such missions before, including previously to Latin America, I will do so again next term.

#"The new Brand Bahamas, similar to the Incredible India campaign, will feature the islands of the Bahamas as a stunningly beautiful, opportunity-rich environment that is stable and strategically located," he said.

#Mr Ingraham also revealed that the government intends to expand the scope of the public sector in Grand Bahama by relocating two government departments here.

#"This will help to stimulate your economy in significant and far-reaching ways," he said.

#"By boosting Grand Bahama's critical infrastructure and the capacity of the public sector here, we are improving the conditions for growth."

#Mr Ingraham said the FNM plans to work with the Grand Bahama Port Authority to improve the prospects for the island.

#"They have ambitious plans, a number of which we will collaborate on in our next term.

#"The Port Authority is moving in a new direction. It is a direction we find quite promising and encouraging," he said.

Comments (0) | TrackBack (0)

Cuba could be key to Caribbean basin

by Patrick Burnson

With the Panama Canal expansion on schedule for completion in 2014, supply chain specialists are anticipating a logistical hub to surface in the Caribbean Basin.
For those investors and traders eyeing opportunities in Cuba, the timing couldn’t be better. As noted in the Wall Street Journal recently, money managers are “optimistic” when it comes to finally eliminating this nation’s 50-year-old trade embargo. And initial barriers to entry should not include logistics, say industry experts.

Furthermore, Cuba may not need outside expertise to cope with immediate supply chain problems. According to some leading scholars and practitioners, Cuba is a sterling example of how to manage “scarcity.” They note that operating under resource scarcity already exists there, with businesses facing daily lack of food, medicine, electricity, and raw materials. View MarketWatch slide show, “The revealing faces of today’s Cuba.”

Despite this, the resourcefulness of Cuba’s people has triumphed to some extent. Reverse logistics experts observe that Cuba has created supply chains that re-use and recycle almost everything, despite the lack of government-mandated recycling programs. Indeed, such adaptation may augur the type of closed loop supply chains needed by other emerging nations in the future.

The long-term challenges around opening trade with Cuba would revolve around the issues of customs and export compliance, in particular the infrastructure to support the safe and fully documented movement of those goods.

With a drive to increase levels of electronic clearance and export documentation, the lack of investment in computerized systems — and the integration of those systems into the U.S. import/export world — would represent a complication, albeit a surmountable one, say compliance experts.

This could be ameliorated, however, by leveraging systems already in place through Cuba’s trade with the EU and Latin America, since our trade embargo with Cuba is increasingly unique.

To the extent that it has the hard currency to support trade at all, Cuba gets most of its imports from the EU and its neighbors to the south. But this can change in a hurry. Automotive parts, technology and manufacturing materials, as well as luxury items particular to the U.S. market are likely to be in high demand.

That said, it is likely that over the long term, U.S.-based producers would seek to build their own infrastructure within Cuba’s boundaries in order to better embed their business into the U.S. market.

According to the World Bank’s Logistics Performance Index, Cuba already performs in the median range. Cuba’s economy is mostly state-controlled, meaning most of the means of production are owned and run by the government.

The London-based Economist Intelligence, meanwhile, ranks the Cuban business environment as one of the world’s worst. In recent years, it was placed as number 80 of 82 nations surveyed, with only Iran and Angola rated lower. However, some forms of foreign investments and private enterprise are allowed. The main sectors of the Cuban economy are industrial production and sugar cultivation. In recent years, tourism, biotechnology and pharmaceutical industry are also gaining importance.

Finally, U.S. investors might wish to look to another hemispheric partner as a model for doing business with this tiny island nation: Canada. Our northern neighbors figured out Cuba’s supply chain long ago.

Canada’s investment, trade and cultural links with Cuba are substantial. In fact, Canada is the second-largest foreign investor in Cuba (after Venezuela) and the third-ranking country in terms of joint ventures. Canada is also Cuba’s fourth-largest merchandise trade partner, behind Venezuela, China, and Spain.

Analysts in Toronto report that a discernible pattern in Canada-Cuba commercial relations to date is that trade has tended to follow investment. In other words, a significant share of Canadian exports to Cuba targets sectors with notable Canadian investments. This is typically the result of an existing synergy between traders and investors that provides clear advantages in the home country and makes commercial sense, not necessarily because of a particular preference for Canadian suppliers.

“Have a Havana?” The supply chain seems ready to oblige. But while rum supplies are likely to meet U.S. demand, tobacco growers and cigar manufacturers are likely to be overwhelmed with orders. As a consequence, industry experts are forecasting a surge in that other great Cuban export: counterfeit Figurados.

Comments (0) | TrackBack (0)

Haiti: Where did the money go?

March 19th, 2012 | by Isabeau Doucet | Published in All Stories, Bureau Recommends

Estimated 50,000 Haitians Set Up Camp on Port-au-Prince Golf Grounds

An estimated 50,000 Haitians set up camp on Port-au-Prince Golf Grounds

After the Caribbean fault lines ripped apart Port-au-Prince, one of the poorest and most densely populated capital cities in the world, over two years ago, Haiti became the recipient of the most generous outpouring of solidarity in the form of disaster relief donations in the history of the United States. One out of every two American households gave a stunning $1.4 billion to a total of 23 major charities, and the international community came together pledging an unprecedented $5 billion – the largest pot of post-disaster reconstruction money ever.


‘People [in Haiti] are very poor, but they’re not stupid. They’re very, very aware that the money was raised with their suffering and their poverty and it’s not being spent on them.’
Linda Polman, journalist and author. 

Here’s the catch: The vast majority of the jackpot was not donated directly to the Haitian people or their elected government, but rather to a proliferation of international NGOs with sophisticated PR apparatuses whose urgent emotional appeals, user friendly donation methods and humanitarian brands made them seem like the natural broker of the emergency aid funds.

The film Haiti: Where did the Money Go? has been aired on dozens of PBS channels across the US, on Capitol hill, in tent camps of Haiti and will today be screened at University of London Union (ULU), tomorrow in Oxford and should be available online in the coming weeks. Though it’s not the most in-depth piece of reporting on post-earthquake accountability in Haiti, and glosses over the country’s complicated history with NGOs, the film’s naiveté does an excellent job of communicating the shocking disparity between the outpouring of money and what’s actually spent on emergency relief for victims of the quake. More importantly, the wide-reach of PBS broadcast has sparked a much-needed debate on the transparency and effectiveness NGOs, which Haiti advocates and the congressional black caucus hope will lead to a congressional inquiry into the work of big NGOs.

A storm of criticism

The American Red Cross and Catholic Relief Service, among those interviewed at length in the film, hit back at PBS criticising the film for “inaccuracies”, “false statements” and “distortions” but their statements have only backfired to reveal how little they actually knew about conditions on the ground.

“We could have been so much harder on the American Red Cross” filmmaker Michele Mitchell told The Bureau of Investigative Journalism, but rather than admitting any regret, says Mitchell “they went nuclear on us.”  They would have been wiser to let the storm of criticism blow over, as their embarrassingly defensive reaction to the film has only confirmed the criticism that they’re more concerned about protecting their brand’s reputation than doing right by the intended beneficiaries of their aid.

During two visits to Haiti ten and twenty months after the earthquake, Mitchell interviews internally displaced camp residents, NGO spokespeople, aid workers, academics and human rights advocates, trying to track down the aid money in the tent camps where as many as 1.5 million displaced Haitians languished at the time.

Viewers accompany her through a visceral journey into a city that looks like it’s been shelled like “Beirut in the 70′s”, a city where the gagging stench of 6 latrines reveals them to be shared by 5,000 camp residents, where people often paid for their tarpaulins and were provided with water that made them sick.

Her first visit coincides with a period when Haiti was facing three full-blown humanitarian emergencies: post-earthquake internal displacement, the outbreak of cholera and hurricane Tomas. Though such simultaneous crises were unprecedented challenges for the UN and NGOs, they had 10 months to prepare for hurricane season and the high possibility of a cholera epidemic, and yet no plans were in place other than instructing camp residents to drop their tents and evacuate to higher ground as the hurricane passed.

Humanitarian code of conduct

There does exists a humanitarian code of conduct for the minimum needs of displaced populations, known as the SPHERE standards, however “there’s no legal requirement” to adhere, says Peter Walker of Tufts University who helped initiate the standard. Nor is there “an industry association that you’re a member of which requires you to deliver to those standard.” The SPHERE was never adhered to in Haiti and accountability often came down to the threat of bad press from journalists.

Haiti was famous for being the republic of NGOs and a graveyard of failed NGO projects even before the earthquake. In the aftermath, at the donor conference in New York where the international community came together to raise money to rebuild, “they swore on the graves of their mothers that this time it would be different” says Linda Polman, Dutch journalist and author whose caustic pen has produced several damning critiques of the NGO “aid caravan”, UN peacekeepers and the relief and reconstruction complex. “People are very poor, but they’re not stupid. They’re very, very aware that the money was raised with their suffering and their poverty and it’s not being spent on them.”


Most aid workers genuinely want to do good, but they also want to have a good time and don’t want to forsake their first world living standards, unfortunately that can look offensive, wasteful, parasitic to the victims on the ground whose tragedy pays their salary.

When asked where the money has gone one resident of an IDP camp says it has gone to “paying for beautiful hotels to sleep in.” The UN themselves say rents have gone up 300%. Mark Schuller, American Anthropologist at CUNY, who has conducted the most definitive field studies of aid in Haiti’s tent camps says “You can call it non-profiteering if you like, you can call it disaster capitalism if you like, but that’s what’s happening right now in Haiti.”

Across the street from a squalid camp where three latrines service an estimated 7, 000 people, fleets of white SUVs line the streets as aid workers and Haiti’s tiny elites frequent a luxury restaurant with an extensive wine menu, tuna tartar, escargot and New York steak at $34. Most aid workers genuinely want to do good, but they also want to have a good time and don’t want to forsake their first world living standards, unfortunately that can look offensive, wasteful, parasitic to the victims on the ground whose tragedy pays their salary.

The films biggest flaws are its over-reliance on American voices to tell of Haiti’s plight, only featuring Haitian voices as victims, while ignoring any Haitian government officials and their critiques of the relief effort.  Limited by the time spent shooting on the ground, the film’s critique of NGOs perhaps doesn’t go far enough, but its mainstream reach is bringing under scrutiny the very important topic of disaster and aid accountability.

Comments (0) | TrackBack (0)

Next »
Subscribe to this blog's feed

Archives

  • May 2012
  • April 2012
  • March 2012
  • February 2012
  • January 2012
  • December 2011
  • November 2011
  • October 2011
  • September 2011
  • August 2011

Categories

  • Air Cargo News
  • Breaking news
  • Caribbean Basin ports
  • Cruise
  • Current Affairs
  • Current Events
  • Customs and BP
  • Cyber attacks
  • Export opportunities
  • Eyerdam links
  • Eyerdam Opinion
  • Follow up
  • Guest Opinion
  • Haiti Shipping Update
  • In Depth Analysis
  • Jobs
  • Latin America ports
  • Logistics
  • Navigation hazards
  • News with a smile
  • Port of Miami River
  • Science
  • Security
  • South Fla. Trade Calendar
  • Southeast Ports
  • Special Report
  • Terraforming Haiti
  • Travel
  • Update
  • US Maritime Highway

About

Blog powered by TypePad
  • South East Shipping News
  • Powered by TypePad